← All open problems

Statistical physics / Open question

Does the thermodynamic arrow reverse in a recollapsing universe?

If a universe stopped expanding and fell back together, would entropy keep rising until the crunch, or would the direction of time flip? The answer shows whether the arrow of time is tied to cosmic expansion or only to the initial state.

OpenSource importedSpecified modelCompiled 2026-11-08

Seed catalog · Showing the bundled record.

Problem statement

For a closed Friedmann universe with matter and radiation that recollapses, with low-entropy initial conditions at the big bang and no imposed final condition, determine whether coarse-grained entropy (including a gravitational contribution) increases monotonically to the big crunch, and whether two-time boundary conditions with low entropy at both ends are consistent with the statistical mechanics of matter plus gravity. Answer: yes or no for monotonic increase, with conditions.

Assumptions and scope

  • Use the model, parameter regime and resolution criterion in the source statement. Additional unstated assumptions require review.

What would settle it?

A statistical-mechanical calculation of entropy evolution through recollapse for a specified matter content, including structure formation and black holes.

Selected for a theoretical or computational target. Numerical evidence alone does not prove an infinite-volume or continuum conjecture.

Status and evidence

Source literature status: open. Hawking argued for reversal in 1985 and later withdrew the claim; no complete statistical treatment exists. Source note marked verified by PubPhys: yes. Theoria has not independently verified this assessment.

Source-imported statement, screened for theory/computation scope. Neither the statement nor its literature status has received an independent specialist review. The compilation date is not a literature-review cutoff.

Source and attribution

Imported from PubPhys, revision 2, under CC BY 4.0. PubPhys identifies its seed as AI-compiled and not individually reviewed. Theoria filters and cross-links the records; source statements and resolution criteria are retained.

Retrieved 2026-11-08T03:19:43.028Z · Record hash: a5cc1b63190c65a4f101c0af029e390545559af1e9a31d7f79353fda95e096d5

Sources and further reading

  1. PubPhys: Does the thermodynamic arrow reverse in a recollapsing universe? ↗source record
  2. J. L. Lebowitz, Statistical mechanics: A selective review of two central issues, Reviews of Modern Physics, 1999 ↗review