← All open problems

Statistical physics / Open question

A coarse-grained entropy for self-gravitating matter

For an ordinary gas, spreading out raises entropy, but under gravity clumping is the likely direction, so the usual formula fails. A gravitational entropy that grows as stars and galaxies form would make the second law consistent from the Big Bang onward.

OpenSource importedSpecified modelCompiled 2026-11-08

Seed catalog · Showing the bundled record.

Problem statement

Construct a coarse-grained entropy functional SgravS_{\mathrm{grav}} for classical self-gravitating systems or perturbed Friedmann spacetimes (for example built from the Weyl tensor, the tidal part of spacetime curvature, following the Weyl curvature hypothesis) that is nondecreasing under gravitational clustering and reduces to the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy A/(4ℓP2)A/(4\ell_{P}^{2}) for black holes. An answer is a definition with a monotonicity proof for a stated class of dynamics, or a no-go result.

Assumptions and scope

  • Use the model, parameter regime and resolution criterion in the source statement. Additional unstated assumptions require review.

What would settle it?

A definition shown to increase monotonically in N-body or perturbed cosmological dynamics and to match black-hole entropy, or a proof that no local functional can.

Selected for a theoretical or computational target. Numerical evidence alone does not prove an infinite-volume or continuum conjecture.

Status and evidence

Source literature status: open. No detailed literature-status note was supplied. Source note marked verified by PubPhys: yes. Theoria has not independently verified this assessment.

Source-imported statement, screened for theory/computation scope. Neither the statement nor its literature status has received an independent specialist review. The compilation date is not a literature-review cutoff.

Source and attribution

Imported from PubPhys, revision 1, under CC BY 4.0. PubPhys identifies its seed as AI-compiled and not individually reviewed. Theoria filters and cross-links the records; source statements and resolution criteria are retained.

Retrieved 2026-11-08T03:19:43.028Z · Record hash: de32b5c0393b62d3a5f83f8f7e14b996194d39066a85ad5aa66f621f97843354

Sources and further reading

  1. PubPhys: A coarse-grained entropy for self-gravitating matter ↗source record
  2. J. L. Lebowitz, Statistical mechanics: A selective review of two central issues, Reviews of Modern Physics, 1999 ↗review