← All open problems

Quantum field theory / Open question

Allowed region of four-photon low-energy coefficients

At low energy, photons scatter off each other weakly, described by a few numbers. Some combinations of these numbers are bounded by first principles, others appear unconstrained, and the full allowed region is unknown.

OpenSource importedSpecified modelCompiled 2026-11-08

Seed catalog · Showing the bundled record.

Problem statement

For the 4D photon effective theory L=−F2/4+a1(FmnFmn)2+a2(FmnFtildemn)2+...L = -F^2/4 + a_1 (F_{mn} F^{mn})^2 + a_2 (F_{mn} Ftilde^{mn})^2 + ..., with no other light states, determine the region of (a1a_1, a2a_2 and higher coefficients, in units of the cutoff) allowed by full nonlinear unitarity, crossing and analyticity, including strongly coupled UV completions, and identify theories on its boundary. Haring, Hebbar, Karateev, Meineri, Penedones (JHEP 10 (2024) 103) obtained numerical bounds and showed that some coefficients cannot be bounded this way.

Assumptions and scope

  • Use the model, parameter regime and resolution criterion in the source statement. Additional unstated assumptions require review.

What would settle it?

Converged numerical bootstrap bounds with an identified family of amplitudes on the boundary.

Selected for a theoretical or computational target. Numerical evidence alone does not prove an infinite-volume or continuum conjecture.

Status and evidence

Source literature status: partially-resolved. Numerical bounds exist since 2022; the sharp region and the theories at its edge are not established. Source note marked verified by PubPhys: yes. Theoria has not independently verified this assessment.

Source-imported statement, screened for theory/computation scope. Neither the statement nor its literature status has received an independent specialist review. The compilation date is not a literature-review cutoff.

Source and attribution

Imported from PubPhys, revision 1, under CC BY 4.0. PubPhys identifies its seed as AI-compiled and not individually reviewed. Theoria filters and cross-links the records; source statements and resolution criteria are retained.

Retrieved 2026-11-08T03:19:43.028Z · Record hash: c3c581cd664b4bb8eb19de87e26e9cad6ae1634c8b1f038059476f9e47e26990

Sources and further reading

  1. PubPhys: Allowed region of four-photon low-energy coefficients ↗source record
  2. M. Kruczenski, J. Penedones, B. C. van Rees, Snowmass White Paper: S-matrix Bootstrap, arXiv:2203.02421, 2022 ↗review